When the Antiques Roadshow comes to Dibley, the villagers bring items to be assessed. David is told that his "priceless" paintings are each worthless imitations, until he puts his fist through the last one in a fit of rage and is told he has just destroyed a valuable Manet. Jim thinks he is on Ready Steady Cook. However, when Alice goes to get her prized Papa Smurf model that her father gave her valued, Geraldine is forced to make the valuer, Hilary Kay, lie about its true worth. When Alice thinks she could sell it for its 'value', Geraldine must sell her TV and ring for Alice.